Categories
Recent Entries

Archives

May 13, 2004

Geocentric Americanism

The world is a great place! I know because I'm out in it travelling around everyday. I can't claim to have been everywhere but by the end of this trip I hope to say I've seen quite a few places, lived in quite a few hostels, and eaten a world of different foods! I love it! How else can you find out so much about yourself and the world at the same time? And there are other things I've discovered along the way I never expected, like how being an American abroad is at times completely embarrassing. And dangerous. Why?

Let me first preface this discussion by letting all my readers know how much I appreciate the liberties and opportunity I have by just being born in the US! I'll never forget the folks who died to give me these liberties. I love my country. Please don't do the American thing and forget that by the end of this entry.

The problem I face, however, deals not with being tucked away safe in my bed at home in the states but with the problems I face being abroad. I began my travels April 7th, 2004,almost two and a half years since 9/11 and the Bush administration taking office. In that time I saw my personal opinion of a Bush led goverment decline to be followed by atrocities such as The Patriot Act among other violations of our civil liberties. Blind patriotism allowed this and has run rampant ever since. And Bush continues to be the cowboy from Texas that we supposedly elected and make decisions that affect the world with only America in mind. Is this right? More importantly, how has the world viewed this?

In New Zealand I met several Americans who would not openly admit they belonged to one of the greatest nationalities in the world. In Australia I met a few who hid their identity with little cloth flags of Canada sewn to their bags. As I approach a trip to Indonesia I am warned to be careful when I leave the hotel. Before I left the US even, my own family pleaded daily with me to stay at home, travel the states like my friends. Why must we hide in a world we help to make free?! The truth lays in the fact that at home in the US we can never fully grasp how universally each decision we make affects the world. People the world over are influenced by our culture on a daily, even hourly basis. Where do most movies come from? Hollywood. Who makes "kiwi style" kethup? Heinz Co. What is discussed on Australian, New Zealand, and European (among many others) radio talk shows? They discuss "Should Bush be re-elected? Is the war in Iraq fair and just? Should we send our boys to help the American coalition?" Right now I feel like we have to hide because we do not make enough peace to justify our wars...or hidden agendas. It seems to me that America is practicing what I call geocentric Americanism where the world revolves around America.

Some claim that we have to behave like we are because of terrorism. "Remember 9/11!!" I remember. I understand terrorism and feel its effects. I cancelled going to the Olympics and Israel because of it. Does this justify a costly in both money and lives "War on Terror" or "liberating" Iraq to install our own American friendly democracy? Is installing a democracy even possible?! I heard that THE PEOPLE must WANT democracy for it to succeed. Better yet, is it UN-American to be asking these questions? Some at home would say yes.

Today on a 100 person group tour in Australia our leader started asking where everyone was from. "Japan?" Hands went straight up. "Britain?" Straight up. "France?" Up. "Israel?" Up. "Canda?" Up. "USA?" ... Heads turn to look for each other. A few slowly raised their hands about shoulder level. An elderly woman from Chicago whispered in my ear "It embarassing these days huh? Lets pray for a change in November." Certainly the feeling of discontent isn't limited to the young or to southerners or Californians or any other traveler for that matter. I shouldn't have to feel embarassed to be from the US. Should I?

So I'm curious to hear about your experiences on the road. Have you had any similar situations like mine? How does it feel to you to be an American on the road? If you're from another country, how do you view Americans on the road? And what should we do?

Let me know.

-Josh

Posted by Josh on May 13, 2004 12:06 PM
Category: Blog-Straight Up!
Comments

Thanks so much for your overseas perspective. It is extremely important for Americans to know the sentiments held by the rest of the world in regards to the U.S. Its simply another reminder that our vote in November is an integral part of creating the future of our world.

Posted by: Heather on May 13, 2004 04:52 PM

Seriously, I hope every American abroad remembers to cast their absentee ballot (I know that there is not a single American abroad who likes Bush, so I don't have to worry about who they're going to vote for :) )

Posted by: Babu on May 14, 2004 11:09 AM

I was impressed to hear the articulate and optimistic thoughts you have expressed. It is sad to hear that you are embarassed to be from the US and worse still that it is dangerous. Yep, I wish you would skip the trips to areas of the world heavily populated and already linked with Islamic extremists i.e. Bali, parts of Indonesia.... it is dangerous. Josh and Amanda... say hello to the world, dont be paranoid, just keep your heads up like any adventurer.

Posted by: Kim on May 14, 2004 10:04 PM

I think its shamful for americans to hide and not speak up about what they are. after all isnt there a little bit of the whole world in every american. after septenber 11 there was a time where if you werent patriototic then u needed to go find another country to live in. i think that still holds and if they are to shy and scared to hold there country high then they can just stay over there! well any hello all and you enjoy your time over there, josh!and personly i dont like bush at all. but what does that matter i cant vote anyway

Posted by: Katy on May 16, 2004 12:35 AM

Hi Josh, I thought your article was really interesting and it's not a topic with easy answers.

For me, I would never advise an American to pretend to be from somewhere else - I just don't think that people connect big politics with individual visitors to their country. I'm English, so sometimes my country is unpopular in places I visit, people have sometimes told me they dislike my country's actions - but never, ever violently.

Around the time of the anniversary of September 11th, I was on holiday in Morocco. Morrocans actually made fun of me because there were so many Islamic fundamentalists living in London! On the day itself, the town I was staying in held a memorial for the victims of September 11th, proclaimed its solidarity with the American people and reminded everyone that Morocco was (apparently) the first country to recognise American Independence. I imagine this event never made the international media - probably less exciting than screaming mobs.

Yes, bad things happen around the world from time to time, but they happen at home too (both mine and yours). I'd recommend reading this article (written by an American):
http://www.gonomad.com/features/0403/cnneffect.html


The second thing I wanted to say was that, rather than geo-centrism, maybe America's problem at the moment is moral-centrism. America is surely supposed to be about ideas like free speech, civil and human rights, strength through diversity. Yet lately anyone criticising America's policies is derided (such as the French government), labelled evil, or, if American, told they should leave the country if they don't like it. Is this freedom? This just seems to be a belief that whatever the American government does must be right by definition.
I realise this is an emotive topic, I'm not trying to slam America - I've spent almost a year of my life travelling and working in the US. But it is just sad the way things are going lately.

I do hope that was more thought provoking than enraging. My (much less political) travel diary is at:
http://blogs.bootsnall.com/dw


Posted by: Daniel on May 17, 2004 12:54 PM

Hey,

I am having fun keeping up with these sites. Hope my spelling doesn't shame you too much. How is your lil' ant eater. Hi, Amanda, keep those communications coming. I feel your pain.

Posted by: Grandma on May 17, 2004 10:16 PM
Email this page
Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):




Designed & Hosted by the BootsnAll Travel Network